therapeutically gazing around (5/5)

This blog is the last in a series on the ‘Medical Gaze’. In the previous blogs I have explored how the eyes of a doctor or therapist may do different things. In the worst case, they only make patients into bodies, and states of illness into a localizable disease, as a machine that needs fixing. Those same eyes, however, may also communicate a level of presence to the suffering of the patient. But ‘gazing medically’ does not stay with doctors in their clinics. 

In this blog I will zoom out from the clinical encounter. I redirect the focus to the Medical Gaze on a larger scale, as it spills over into our societies. Yes, even if you have never seen a doctor, you will have met the Medical Gaze. 

You may even be gazing medically yourself.

YOUR MEDICAL GAZE

The media are one channel that can “spread” the Medical Gaze. In the US, psycho-pharmacological medication is advertised directly to ‘consumers’. Are you familiar with such advertisements? This does not happen in the Netherlands, where I am. I would assume such advertisements will make you scan your personal experiences and interiors, “am I in need of this pill?”. And when you do, you translate these experiences into a medical condition. For example, experiences of low mood can be turned into depression. Or your neighbor or the teacher of your child may suggest the label of ADHD as an explanation for your child’s behavior. And there it is: a medical condition is born, through your own eyes.

ALL-SEEING MEDICAL GAZE

There are fears that bio-medicine is reaching out too widely. It is taking more and more phenomena into its area of investigation, and presents them as amenable to medical treatment. You could say those phenomena are "grabbed out of our hands, our bodies, our lives, and put into labs, randomized control trials and clinics."

Medicalization can evoke push-back. One obvious example is the classification of homosexuality as a mental disorder in the DSM (Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders) until 1973. Should a sexual orientation be classified as a mental illness that is in need of treatment? And should others think alike, medically gazing at gay people as somehow diseased? Gay rights activists in this case stood up to have the label removed.

Woman doctor

MULTIPLE GAZES

When discussing what physical and mental ailments are and what to do with them, doctors are not the only ones sitting around the table. They may have the priority seats, but at the end of the day we are all sitting at that table. 

What do you (as a yoga therapist) bring to that table?

Rokus Loopik started The Living Musuem in Bennebroek, where people with (and without) a psychiatric diagnosis are invited to make art, leaving their diagnosis behind the moment they enter the museum. A space is opened up for them to explore themselves and their experiences in new and authentic ways. This is a place where the Medical Gaze is intentionally excluded, so that other gazes can arise. This project inspires many, including health care managers, to think differently about the potential of mental health care.

I think it is important to keep inviting different perspectives to the table, and have productive cross-fertilizing discussions about important issues as disease, health, treatments, and the organization of health care.

Do you feel the need to engage in conversations about the ways in which we can perceive or treat disease, and how healthcare could be organized? Do you have a chance to do so?

You like what you read?

Sign-up for the newsletter and receive updates and more!

HI, I AM Niki

Niki Haak

I am a research master student in Religious Studies and completed the Yoga Teacher Training with Network Yoga Therapy . In these blogs I aim to share with you some of the thoughts and reflections that I gather along the way. Please leave comments and share your thoughts!

Start typing and press Enter to search

>